익명 07:47

although not a yacht/adverb placement

although not a yacht/adverb placement

a. Although not a yacht, I managed to buy a car.

b. I managed to buy a car, although not a yacht.

I think in theory there are two possible meanings:

  1. I managed to buy a car instead of a yacht.

  2. I managed to buy a car, but not a yacht as well.

Would you say that both meanings are possible both in the case of (a) and (b)?

Many thanks.



Top Answer/Comment:

"Although" means despite the fact that, or despite being. It highlights a contrast between two things, rather than a relationship. It does not mean "instead" or "not as well". So, sadly, neither of your interpretations is correct.

A yacht is typically far more expensive than a car. If one only just "manages" (succeeds with some difficulty) to buy a car, they likely could not afford a yacht.

The implication with both sentences (although I find the first more idiomatic) is that the person would like to buy a yacht, and perhaps even previously stated that desire, but is taking consolation in the fact that they achieved something lesser in affording a car.

Consider:

Although I didn't win, I managed to come in second place.

The person wanted to win, but didn't; however, they came second, which is the next best thing. Obviously, one cannot come in first and second place, so this nicely demonstrates that they can be mutually exclusive.

상단 광고의 [X] 버튼을 누르면 내용이 보입니다